April 07, 2022 | By Steve Horvath
Full blog document
Nickelback sings: 'Cause we all just wanna be big rockstars…
Many people insist that politics exist wherever there are multiple people involved, but politics are neither necessary, nor desirable in the common interest communities (CICs).
Serv·ice [ˈsərvəs]
- the action of helping or doing work for someone
Pol·i·tics [ˈpäləˌtiks]
- the activities associated with the governance of a country or other area, especially the debate or conflict among individuals or parties having or hoping to achieve power
- activities within an organization that are aimed at improving someone's status or position and are typically considered to be devious or divisive
- a particular set of political beliefs or principles
Following the tragic, partial collapse of Champlain Towers South in June 2021, the entire world took a closer look at the machinations within CICs and in particular how years-long delays debating multi-million dollar structural repairs may have contributed to the unfortunate outcome. The Guardian reported that “Emails, letters, notes and presentations from meetings of the residents’ association board revealed infighting…”
There are, of course, debates as to whether the volunteer leaders of Champlain Towers fully understood the full gravity and urgency of the situation, but in the end it seems that politics played a decisive role in at least the delay of repairs, if not the deaths of nearly 100 people.
The definitions of service and politics present an intriguing juxtaposition. In the CIC context, the activities associated with governance are often the result of doing work for members of the community (which includes, in this case, both unit owners and other residents). On the flip side, debate or conflict among individuals or parties having or hoping to achieve power and activities … aimed at improving someone’s status or position are not necessary outcomes of helping or doing work for someone.
Debate and germane conflict should be celebrated as natural parts of unique individuals working through decision-making. If everyone on a five person Board agrees about every decision with little to no debate and/or discussion, there may well be an underlying lack of due diligence (which courts have ruled violates the basic duty of care). The source of politics in CIC governance often plays out due to a fundamental misalignment between what an individual wants and what’s best for the CIC. Moreover, CIC politics isn’t limited solely to directors and committee members.
In a recent example, a staff member sent a message detailing his intent to interfere with a unit owner’s overdue replacement of a broken limited common element. Why? This staff member believed that “transparency” about the potential for the component to break again if replaced by the same material was most important. In this case, “transparency” really means that the CIC becomes an interloper in a unit owner’s like-for-like replacement, potentially creating an architectural application and design review process that need not exist. “Help” and “transparency” should never create a conflict of interest benefitting one owner at the expense of the CIC.
That example highlights challenges that arise when one owner’s interests are placed before the interests of the whole. The needs of one vs. the needs of many may be the simplest way to summarize the overarching governance concept of all CIC experience. Serving the greater good, the good of the many, must always be the goal. To that end, every CIC should adopt a code of ethics that includes clear statements directing individuals to work as a team and set aside their own ambitions and priorities.
Just as often, politics comes into play with annual Director elections and Board officer appointments. How often have you been witness to promises being made that: 1) are not in the best interest of your CIC and/or 2) that never come to fruition, but make great sound bites for the purpose of rallying support to achieve an election result? When your Board appoints officers, do your Directors actually take into account who can deliver the best results for your CIC based on a detailed understanding of what each position entails? Do you vote based on a popularity contest, or based on a pragmatic approach that will help achieve great outcomes? Does your Board appoint officers based on their experience and knowledge, or based on political bias?
Human beings are inexorably tied to many forms of bias. Setting those biases aside is challenging, but it can be done by choice. Intentional leadership, as opposed to accidental leadership, is the only way to avoid politics in CICs. Only when individuals made the conscious decision to put the CIC first can politics be put in their place. Follow your North Star sums it up well:
...a board member's North Star is found in the answer to a simple question: "What is best for the community?"
If board members focus on that, their jobs become relatively straightforward. They don't make decisions based on their own personal interests or the interests of their friends or neighbors. They don't make decisions based on what's least likely to create conflict or controversy. They don't make decisions based on what's expedient or easy...
ROCK your CIC by asking:
“what’s best for the entire community?”

'Cause we all just wanna be big rockstars…
Julius Caesar Image by GDJ from Pixabay
Crowd Carry image by westphotoandvideo from Pixabay
Service Image by Nick Verlaan from Pixabay
